Market Notes
The Market Just Did Something That Happens Once Every 190 Years. Again.
The S&P 500 closed 4.1 standard deviations below its 50-day average on Friday, a reading the bell curve says comes along twice a millennium. It has now shown up in 1987, 2011, 2015 and this week. The math is wrong, the history is encouraging, and the plan was written in advance.
Written by Drew Sweetman
Founder, Element Squared Private Wealth

On Friday the S&P 500 closed 4.1 standard deviations below its 50-day moving average. If you believe the textbook, that is supposed to happen about once every 190 years. The record says it has now happened in 1987, 2011, 2015 and this week, which is four times in about 40 years, or roughly once a decade. Either the market is extraordinarily unlucky, or the textbook has some explaining to do. We think clients deserve the second answer, so here it is.
The setup
1. What just happened, in plain English
The 50-day moving average is the market's recent "normal," the average closing price over the last ten weeks. A standard deviation is how far prices usually wander from that normal. Most days the S&P 500 sits within one standard deviation of its average, like a dog on a leash. Two is a hard tug. Three is the dog spotting a squirrel. Four is the leash snapping and the dog disappearing over the horizon.
By Friday's close the index was about 9 percent below its 50-day average and about 12 percent below the record it set on October 6. The last time it moved this far, this fast, relative to its own recent behavior was August 2015. Before that, August 2011. Before that, October 1987. You will notice that none of those are months anyone remembers fondly.
2. About that "once every 190 years"
The 190-year figure comes from assuming market returns follow a bell curve. Under a bell curve, a four-standard-deviation day is a two-in-100,000 event, and with 252 trading days a year that works out to roughly once every two centuries. It is a lovely piece of arithmetic. It is also the same arithmetic that said 2008 could not happen, and 1987, and most of the other things that did.
Markets do not follow a bell curve. They have what statisticians politely call "fat tails," which is the technical term for "the extreme stuff happens about ten times more often than the formula says." Mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot spent decades pointing this out and was largely ignored by people who found the bell curve easier to put on a slide. Four "once-in-190-years" events in 40 years is not bad luck. It is the market reminding us, roughly once a decade, that it did not read the textbook.
A footnote for the sticklers: by our count August 1990 also squeaked past the four-standard-deviation line, so you can call it five if you like. And March 2020 does not make the list at all, because the market fell so fast that the standard deviation itself ran away before the reading could register. Statistics are funny that way.
Our models carry written rules for weeks like this one. We will walk you through what they did on Friday, what they do next, and how your current portfolio compares.
3. What happened next, the last four times
Since the internet is going to spend the weekend comparing this to 1987, it is worth looking at what the S&P 500 actually did in the twelve months after each of these readings. All four are below, measured from the day the index first crossed the line.
| Date | S&P 500 close | Std. deviations below 50-day | S&P 500 twelve months later |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 19, 1987 | 225 | 5.6 | +24% |
| August 6, 1990 | 334 | 4.1 | +17% |
| August 8, 2011 | 1,119 | 4.3 | +25% |
| August 21, 2015 | 1,971 | 4.4 | +11% |
| November 20, 2026 | 6,910 | 4.1 | Ask us in a year |
Four for four, with an average gain of about 19 percent. That is encouraging, and we want to be the first to say it is also a sample size you could fit in a minivan. Four observations do not make a law. What they do make is a useful reminder: in every prior case, the scary reading arrived near the worst of the selling, not the start of it. The people who sold on the day the headline printed were, each time, selling to someone who did very well.
It is also worth noting what the reading does not tell you. It says nothing about why the market fell, whether the reason is serious, or whether next week is better. It only says that prices moved unusually far from their recent average, unusually quickly. Sometimes that is the end of the story and sometimes it is the first chapter. Nobody knows which on the day, including, and especially, the people who sound most certain.
The reading
Four standard deviations below the 50-day average. Rare, scary, and historically closer to the end of the selling than the start.
The math
"Once in 190 years" assumes a bell curve. Markets have fat tails. Expect this roughly once a decade, not once a lifetime.
The plan
Rules written in advance, rebalancing into weakness, harvesting losses, and a conversation about what the money is actually for.
Sources
Prices: Yahoo Finance, S&P 500 index (^GSPC) daily closes through November 20, 2026. The 50-day moving average is the simple average of the prior 50 closes; the standard deviation is the population standard deviation of the same 50 closes. Episodes are the first day the close fell four or more standard deviations below the average, with at least 120 days between episodes. Twelve-month returns are price returns from that close to the first trading day on or after the same date one year later, excluding dividends. The "once every 190 years" figure is the normal-distribution probability of a reading at or below −4.1 standard deviations (about 0.002 percent per day) applied to 252 trading days per year. Benoit Mandelbrot and Richard Hudson, The (Mis)Behavior of Markets, Basic Books, 2004. Nothing here is a forecast; past selloffs recovering is not a guarantee that this one will.
Important disclosures
Not investment advice. This commentary is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It reflects the opinions of Element Squared as of the date shown, which may change without notice, and it is not personalized investment advice, an offer, or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any strategy. Any investment decision should follow a full review of your objectives, risk tolerance, time horizon, tax situation, liquidity needs and other holdings, ideally with a qualified professional.
Securities and indices mentioned. References to specific companies, funds, indices or price levels are for illustration only and are not recommendations. Element Squared, its clients or its employees may hold positions in securities discussed and may change those positions at any time without notice.
Risk of loss. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance, whether actual or hypothetical, is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future results. Historical market patterns described here may not repeat, and indicators or frameworks discussed may fail to anticipate future market behavior.
Data and forward-looking statements. Market data is drawn from third-party sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed for accuracy or completeness. Statements about future events, scenarios or outcomes are forward-looking, involve uncertainty, and may not come to pass. An investor cannot invest directly in an index.
Registration and fiduciary status. Advisory services are offered through Element Squared LLC, doing business as Element Squared Private Wealth, an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. As a registered investment adviser, Element Squared is a fiduciary and is required to act in its clients' best interests. Additional information, including Form ADV Part 2A and the firm's Client Relationship Summary, is available upon request and at adviserinfo.sec.gov.
Free guide
Your old 401(k), in four parts.
What happens to it, what it costs you to leave it, and how a rollover actually works.
Get the guide →Keep reading
All insights →
Market Notes
Chase Momentum or Buy What’s Hated? It Depends on Your Calendar
Semiconductors are down 35 percent from June. Health care and staples are at highs. One camp says ride the trend, the other says buy the wreck. Forty years of research says both are right, on different clocks.

Market Notes
The “Affair Rally”: We Fact-Checked the Internet’s Worst Trading Strategy
A viral meme says stocks soar after the boss gets caught cheating. We recomputed every number, then read the 325-case study that says the opposite. We do not condone any of it.

Market Notes
15 Things in Anthropic’s IPO Filing You Won’t Believe Are Real
It lost $80 billion while turning a profit, its AI writes 90 percent of its code, and one share of stock controls the company. The strangest IPO prospectus ever filed, in 15 facts.
